Leadership & People
Research insight
May 13, 2021

A multi-level approach to direct and indirect relationships between organizational voice climate, team manager openness, implicit voice theories, and silence

Abstract:

Employee silence impedes sustainable organizational development, and it can conceal harm for internal and external stakeholders. Established approaches to overcoming silence in organizations draw on the assumption that employees withhold their views based on deliberate elaborations on the effectiveness and risks they associate with voice. Our research aims at complementing these approaches. Applying an information processing approach to culture and using implicit voice theories (IVTs; i.e., taken-for-granted beliefs about when and why speaking up at work is risky or inappropriate) as an example, we introduce a model proposing ways through which shared implicit knowledge structures emerge in teams and organizations, and how they affect motives to remain silent. We examine parts of the model with a sample of 696 employees nested in 129 teams and 67 organizations. Our findings show that IVTs can be shared at the team and organizational level, that shared IVTs explain variance in silence motives above and beyond perceptions of organizational climate and manager openness at the team and organization level, and that IVTs function as a mediator between team manager openness and silence motives. In sum, our findings point at shared IVTs as a way to conceptualize underlying basic assumptions of cultures of silence.


Authors: Michael Knoll, Pedro Neves, Birgit Schyns, Bertolt Meyer


You can find the research article here.

Nova SBE Leadership for Impact Knowledge Center

Nova SBE Leadership for Impact Knowledge Center

Website
8. Decent work and economic growth
Leadership & People
Webinar
SDG
8
17

Where to focus

As we adjust to remote working, how do we move from turbulence and stand-by, and start re-focusing our teams and organizations on the future?

Learn more
Leadership & People
Research insight
SDG
8

"Elgar Introduction to Organizational Paradox Theory" - Book Launch!

This is the latest book by Miguel Pina e Cunha, co-authored with Marco Berti (UTS Business School), Ace Simpson (Brunel Business School) and Stewart R. Clegg (University of Stavanger Business School and Nova SBE). It will be released in July 2021 and comprises a succinct overview of the field of organizational paradox theory, exploring contradictions and tensions in organizational settings. By conceptually mapping the field, it offers guidance through the literature on paradox, giving space for new interpretations and applications of the concept.

Learn more
Leadership & People
Project
SDG
4
10
16

Inclusive Community Forum

The Inclusive Community Forum (ICF) is a Nova SBE initiative addressing the lives of people with disabilities that seeks to promote a more inclusive community by building a network composed of all those who intervene in the lives of these people, challenging them to play an active role in co-creating solutions.

Learn more