Africa & Development
Research insight
INVITED EDITOR
Editorial from
Mariana Esteves
MSc. Alumna and currently Researcher at Nova School of Business and Economics
November 16, 2022
1. No poverty

1. No poverty

Eradicate poverty in all its forms everywhere
LEARN MORE

10. Reduced inequalities

Reduce inequalities within countries and between countries
LEARN MORE

More redistribution? Yes, please.

OECD data show that in Portugal, it can take up to five generations for descendants of a low-income family to reach the national average income. Mariana Esteves, Researcher at Nova SBE, explores the topic of redistribution in Portugal.

OECD data show that in Portugal, it can take up to five generations for descendants of a poor family to reach the national average income.

In the aftermath of the 2008 crisis and in the face of rising unemployment and the deterioration of living conditions, the streets were filled to demand a fairer, less unequal, and more socially protected society. Today, the Covid-19 crisis further aggravates the inequality gap, as revealed by the Covid-19 Barometer from the National School of Public Health (ENSP).

The growing concentration of income among the wealthiest remains one of our time's main social issues and a reflection of the inability of public policies to provide equal opportunities and fairness in the distribution of income. Here, too, Portugal is no exception. According to Eurostat data, in 2018, the poorest 20% Portuguese hold only 8% of the national disposable income, while the richest 20% hold more than 40% of that income. As for social mobility, OECD data show that it can take up to five generations for descendants of a poor family to reach the national average income in Portugal.

How does the social elevator's ineffectiveness - or, more precisely, the perception of this ineffectiveness - affect citizens' support for more State intervention in the distribution of income?

In 2018, three economists from Harvard University sought to answer this question. In the United States, the country of the “American dream”, redistribution preferences are less. In European countries, where confidence in the social elevator is low, citizens prefer higher redistribution and public intervention levels. These attitudes are deeply rooted in historical differences, whose memory seems to last. While Europe has gone through centuries of feudal regimes, in which to be rich, it was necessary to be born rich, in the United States, the first generations of wealthy individuals were immigrants who arrived in the "land of opportunity" poor.

Portugal appears to be the most European of all European countries. In a study conducted in September 2019, replicating the analysis of Harvard economists for the Portuguese case, compared to the Americans and our European neighbors, we found that we are the ones who least believe that it is possible to climb alone. In 2018, a Eurobarometer report showed that, compared to the European average, the Portuguese are 38% less confident in the likelihood of themselves rising in life. Additionally, in Portugal, factors such as “being lucky”, “being from a wealthy family” and “having political connections” are considered more important to ascend the social elevator compared to citizens of other European Union countries.

Does this lack of confidence in the social elevator translate into greater support for the welfare state, in line with Harvard economists' results? The answer, in the study we did, is a definite 'yes'. The Portuguese are fervent supporters of redistributive policies, both in terms of taxes (e.g., progressive taxes on income, taxation on capital), and in terms of public expenditure (public investment in education, health, and social security). Eurobarometer data validates our conclusions: 96% of Portuguese people consider that Portugal's income differences are excessive, and 94% want the government to act to mitigate this inequality.

Portugal is still an unequal country with poor social mobility, as revealed by Eurostat and OECD data from 2018. The data we collected before the pandemic and the results of the 2018 Eurobarometer show that the Portuguese chose to respond to inequalities with more public policies that promote income redistribution through taxes and more public spending. Today, with the dramatic increase in social inequalities, how will we choose to mitigate the unprecedented socioeconomic vulnerabilities that lie ahead? With more redistribution, please.

This article can be found in Portuguese here, in Jornal Económico

Mariana Esteves
MSc. Alumna and currently Researcher at Nova School of Business and Economics
LEARN MORE
SHARE

Keep reading

Usage of Electronic Payments by Small Business Owners in Mozambique

This study diagnoses the access to banking and electronic payments (POS, Mobile Banking and Mobile Money) by small businesses in the cities of Mozambique.

Gold mining in Burkina Faso: Who wins?

While the state benefits more from industrial than artisanal mining, only artisanal mines increase the consumption of local populations. Read through this research insight, co-authored by Victoire Girard, FCT Researcher at Nova SBE, and Rémi Bazilier, Professor of Economics, Patheon-Sorbonne University.

Fleeing migrants. "These people are desperate"

Cátia Batista, scientific director of the Nova SBE NOVAFRICA Knowledge Center, calls for policies to welcome and integrate migrants.

Is mobile money changing the rural landscape? Evidence from Mozambique

The introduction of mobile money promoted migration out of rural areas by easing long-distance transfers and increasing resilience. Professors Cátia Batista and Pedro Vicente, Founders and Scientific Directors of Nova SBE NOVAFRICA Knowledge Center, recently reflected on mobile money as an opportunity for financial inclusion.

THE CHOICES OF

Peak performance: Kilimanjaro leadership quest

In September 2023, Nova School of Business and Economics (Nova SBE) made history as 16 faculty and staff members embarked on an extraordinary journey — the Kilimanjaro Leadership Quest. This ambitious project saw the team conquer Africa's highest peak, Mount Kilimanjaro, imparting invaluable leadership, teamwork, and sustainability lessons.

Subscribe our weekly newsletter

By subscribing to the Nova SBE Role to Play newsletter, you can stay up-to-date on the latest articles posted on the website.
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

We all have a role to play

We are on a mission to be a community dedicated to the development of talent and knowledge that impacts the world.

With just ten years to go, an ambitious global effort is underway to deliver the 2030 promise. We want to take a stand and we are calling on our community to showcase how they are contributing to the 17 Sustainable Development Goals, whilst influencing more and more people to unravel their role to play.

Here, you will find four different ways your ideas can flourish, dialogue can be enhanced, and action can take place. You can choose one or all four, and Nova SBE will be there to support you all the way and guarantee tangible change.

We all have a role to play, and this is your way in.