Economics
Opinion Article
December 15, 2020

Labor Income Tax Progressivity and Fiscal Multipliers

Labor Income Tax Progressivity and Fiscal Multipliers

‍

Fiscal consolidation programs to reduce or stabilize government deficits and public debt, often achieved through increased taxation, decreased government spending or a combination of the two, have repercussions on output. To measure and represent these impacts of fiscal programs on output, economists usually construct fiscal multipliers, whose accuracy is essential to design policies with reduced risk of setting unachievable fiscal targets or a miscalculated amount of adjustments necessary, and to make better predictions of output growth, since in the context of substantial changes between stimulus and consolidation, fiscal policies may be one of the larger forces impacting output.

Β 

In order to potentially ease computations, it was conducted an analysis of a particular aspect within this subject: whether there is a relationship between heterogeneity in labor income tax progressivity and the impact of fiscal policies on output, in the particular context of fiscal consolidation programs. In other words, if the multiplicity of fiscal multipliers across time and economies may be in part a reflection of differences in labor income tax progressivity.

Β 

In that respect, considering different levels of progressivity (πœƒ1), a standard life-cycle model with heterogenous agents and uninsurable idiosyncratic risk for the U.S. was calibrated ten times, followed by a fiscal experiment of a 50-year reduction in government debt financed through a decrease in government spending (G) or through an increase in labor income tax (πœπ‘™ ).

‍

Figure 1: Impact multiplier for the G-consolidation for different values of progressivity measure.
Figure 2: Relationship between the percentage of borrowing constrained agents in the economy and progressivity.

Spending fiscal multipliers and labor income tax progressivity: The study reveals a negative relationship between fiscal multipliers resulting from a decrease in government spending (Impact Multiplier G) and progressivity, which means that the recessionary impacts of these programs are smaller as labor income tax progressivity increases (Fig.1). Additionally, it is shown a positive relationship between progressivity and borrowing constraints (Fig. 2). As labor tax progressivity benefits comparatively the bottom agents by exempt them from paying taxes or to be taxed lower rates, these agents have lower incentives to incur in precautionary savings, which entail a higher number of borrowing constrained agents. In turn,the lower government debt leads to an increase in the expected life-time income, which conducts to a decrease of labor supply and consequently a drop in output in the short run. However, constrained agents face an impediment to decrease labor today from the higher expected life-time income which leads to the outcome above mentioned.

‍

Figure 3: Impact multiplier for the πœπ‘™-consolidation for different values of labor income tax progressivity.

‍

Increased taxation and labor income tax progressivity: There is also a negative relationship between fiscal multipliers resulting from increasing taxation (Impact Multiplier 𝝉𝒍) and labor income tax progressivity. However, in this case it means that as progressivity increases the recessionary impact of these programs are larger (Fig. 3). The lower multiplier indicates that higher progressivity leads to higher distortionary effects in the economy (it diverges the economy away from optimality), since the percentage of the labor supply after consolidation of the labor supply in steady state is decreasing as progressivity increases for all percentiles of the economy and the expected life time income decreases for all age groups. The literature on fiscal multipliers have been enabling decision makers to set better policies that contribute to the welfare of societies by promoting economic growth. The results reported here emerge as an effort to further research on this issue and to improve the elaboration process of fiscal programs

‍

Mariana Santos

Mariana Santos

MSc. student in Economics from Nova SBE

Website
8. Decent work and economic growth
Image of sparks.
Economics
Research insight
SDG
8

Essays on financial frictions

For the past forty years, the global economy has faced many challenges, including the increasing complexity and sophistication of financial markets, which created a new type of frictions that were in the origin of several recessive episodes such as the 2008 financial crisis. In her PhD thesis, Erica Marujo analyzes the role of financial frictions as a source of business cycle fluctuations.

Learn more
Economics
Opinion Article
SDG
16

American lessons

When they are excluded, people do not change to be included, they become more radical, they stop listening and start working in a closed circuit. It is a very human reaction to denying reality.

Learn more
Bank.
Economics
Research insight
SDG
16

Three essays on banks’ operational risk disclosures in the European Union: the role of informal institutions, and the association with performance

In her PhD thesis, Florence Basto explores the relationship between both, informal institutions and performance, and operational risk disclosures in the European Union banking industry.

Learn more